Can You Put a Metal Roof Over Shingles?

Installing metal over an existing shingle roof skips the tear-off, so it's tempting. Sometimes the code allows it and it works. Often a tear-off is the better roof. Here's what the residential code says, what goes wrong, and how we decide.

Open 24/7 · 2204 W Anderson Ln, Austin, TX 78757

The Short Answer

  1. The residential code allows a recover over existing roofing in some cases, if the manufacturer's instructions allow it.
  2. A recover is not allowed when the roof already has two or more layers.
  3. It's also not allowed over a water-soaked or deteriorated roof, or over slate, clay or cement tile.
  4. Skipping tear-off hides the deck, so rot and soft spots go unrepaired under a roof meant to last decades.
  5. Your local building department and the panel manufacturer have the final say.
The code

When a recover isn't allowed

SituationRecover allowed?
One existing layer of asphalt shingles, sound deck, manufacturer allows itPossibly, subject to local code and permit
Two or more existing layersNo
Existing roof water-soaked or deterioratedNo
Existing slate, clay, cement or asbestos-cement tileNo
Existing wood shakesMetal is allowed with additional requirements

Based on the International Residential Code reroofing section (R908 in recent editions). Austin's adopted edition and amendments, and your panel manufacturer's instructions, govern your project. This is not code or legal advice.

The trade-offs

Why we usually recommend tear-off

You can't see the deck

Tear-off is the only way to find and replace soft or rotted decking. Under a recover, it stays hidden.

Fastening is harder

Fasteners must go through the old shingles and still hold in the deck. Old, uneven shingles make that less consistent.

Uneven surfaces show

Ridges and humps in old shingles can telegraph through flat metal panels and add to oil canning.

Flashing gets compromised

Wall, chimney and valley flashing works best rebuilt from the deck up, not layered over old details.

Added weight

A recover adds load on top of the existing roof. Metal is light, but it's still more weight.

Moisture and heat

Old shingles under metal can trap moisture and change how the attic ventilates if the details aren't right.

When it can make sense

How we decide

On a single layer of flat, sound shingles over a solid deck, with a panel system whose manufacturer allows it and a building department that will permit it, a recover can work, especially on outbuildings and some exposed fastener roofs. Some installers also run purlins or battens over the old roof to create a new, flat nailing surface. We'll check the layer count, walk the deck for soft spots, look in the attic, and tell you which approach makes sense, in writing.

For most homes, we recommend metal roof replacement with a full tear-off: the deck gets inspected and repaired, and the new roof starts flat. See metal roof vs. shingles if you're still deciding on metal, oil canning on metal roofs for why a flat surface matters, and the metal roof cost guide for how tear-off affects price. For residential metal roofing, the conversion process is laid out step by step.

We get asked this on most shingle-to-metal estimates for metal roofing in Austin. If one Austin metal roofing bid is much lower than the rest, check whether it skips the tear-off. Every quote for a metal roof in Austin should say so plainly, and our metal roofing in Austin, TX estimates always do.

Related

More from Austin Metal Roofing Pros

Browse all Austin metal roofing services, compare metal roof systems in Austin, or read more Austin metal roofing guides.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Can you put a metal roof over shingles in Austin?

Sometimes. The residential code allows a recover over one existing layer in some situations if the manufacturer allows it, but not over two or more layers or a deteriorated roof. Your permit and the manufacturer's instructions decide.

Is it cheaper to put metal over shingles?

It skips tear-off and disposal, so the upfront cost is usually lower. The trade-off is that the deck goes uninspected under a roof meant to last decades.

How many layers of roofing are allowed?

Under the residential code, a recover isn't allowed when the roof already has two or more layers of any roof covering.

Do I need a permit to put metal over shingles?

Many jurisdictions require a permit for reroofing. Check with your city's building department before the work starts.

Tear-Off or Recover?

Call (512) 501-4970, open 24/7, or request an estimate. We'll check layers, deck and attic and recommend in writing.

Austin Metal Roofing Pros · 2204 W Anderson Ln, Austin, TX 78757 · Open 24/7